Friday, September 01, 2006

Apple Choosing An Interesting Direction Concerning Litigation

As reported by MacMinute:


Report: Apple settles iTunes patent case

A story on Macworld UK today notes that Apple has settled an iTunes-related lawsuit which claimed the company stole the application's design from another party. "David Contois, owner of Contois Music and Technology, claimed that he demonstrated digital jukebox software at a tradeshow a decade ago, notes the report. "He filed a lawsuit in June 2005 stating: 'Apple has copied the invention. Apple's infringement has been and continues to be willful.'" The story goes on to note: "He wanted damages and fees, and also wanted Apple to be barred from distributing iTunes software. Apple filed a counterclaim in response to Conois' actions, but the case was amicably concluded in an undisclosed settlement in a US court yesterday, according to a local report.


Interesting choices Apple is making lately to just settle instead of pursue litigation. Personally I'm all for it. I think it's better for parties to mediate and settle. It also allows the defendant to see motivation behind a suit. An entity that will not settle is usually indicative of malicious or vindictive motif. I'm not sure how stockholders are going to like the "profits to less protraction" money exchange though.

No comments: